Of my current herd of kitties, there are three clear favorites from the basket of toys. Jesse is especially fond of little stuffed mice, most of which are disemboweled now. Sam loves, LOVES, loves his catnip fish. And Cinders is a sheer fiend for the traditional feather on a stick. Gidget's favorite toy is A Lap. She's not much for playing. Unless it's a laser 'bug'. Laser bugs are ferociously chased by all four.

In the 'you weird thing' category:
My beloved Bear was very fond of a teensy little fiberfill mitten and boot that he pulled off a Christmas decoration.
Currently, Cinders has a couple of plastic pieces from a fake flower that she adores batting around. She's also keen on leaves from the ponytail palm.